Some studies have revealed that the environmental impact of e-commerce is lower than that caused by physical stores. However, online shopping is not zero-impact and there is still a long way to go to raise awareness among brands and consumers on the issue of environmental sustainability. But why does e-commerce pollute? And what can we do to solve the problem?
E-commerce and physical stores compared
E-commerce continues to grow, driven in part by new shopping behaviors that have become widespread due to the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the B2C E-commerce Observatory, in the Italian market alone, the value of online purchases reached 39.4 billion euros in 2021, marking a 21% increase compared to the previous year.
What impact can this trend have at the environmental level? The consulting firm Oliver Wyman has conducted research to understand the impact of e-commerce on the environment and the economy. The report analyzed the purchasing process for books, consumer electronics, and apparel in 5 European countries: France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom.
A significant finding emerged from the study, namely that On average, online shopping is less polluting than offline shopping and therefore more advantageous in terms of sustainability. In fact, traditional stores cause between 1.5 and 2.9 times more greenhouse gas emissions than e-commerce. In Italy, for example, the consumption is 1764 grams of CO2e* for physical retail and 898 grams of CO2e for online retail (nearly half!).
Let's take a look at this table showing the pollution rate caused by the same product sold via e-commerce and physical retail. What are the factors that have the biggest impact?

On average, the pollution caused by a product purchased offline is 1,970 grams of CO2e emissions. The same product purchased online, however, causes “only” 815 grams.
In case of brick-and-mortar store, The 60% emission value is derived from the building energy consumption (1,184 grams of CO2e, compared to 163 for e-commerce) and the 30% from the consumer journey to the store (596 grams of CO2e).
Instead, the factor that has the greatest impact in the case of’e-commerce in terms of pollution, it is last-mile delivery (215 grams of CO2e, equal to 26% of the total). The packaging emits an additional 114 g of CO2e compared to the offline store.
È vero che l’ecommerce richiede l’utilizzo di furgoni per effettuare le consegne a domicilio, ma reduces automobile travel traffic by 4 to 9 times consumers from their home to the store. In addition, e-commerce does not need physical spaces dedicated to sales nor large parking lots, even if it requires two or three times more space for order processing.
Does e-commerce pollute?
The statistics we saw show that e-commerce is less harmful to the environment than offline commerce. However, this does not mean that online shopping has a zero impact! There is still much to be done to raise awareness among brands and consumers about the problem of environmental impact and to implement new, more sustainable strategies.
For example, a factor that affects the greenhouse gas emissions of e-commerce is the location of the warehouses and sorting centers. The growth of European cities has led to the relocation of logistics facilities away from urban centers. What is the consequence? An increase in last-mile transport fragmentation and, consequently, in pollution.
Plus, there is the issue of’packaging, which has a particularly significant impact in e-commerce and often consists of non-recyclable materials of different types. The current trend is toward finding solutions made from a single, recyclable material. Amazon, for example, has introduced easy-open packaging made from 100% recyclable cardboard to reduce plastic use as much as possible.
Another aspect not to be underestimated is that of receipt. Allowing customers to return the product (for whatever reason) improves their Customer Journey, but what impact can it have on the environment? Returning goods means doubling the transport route and therefore the greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere. In short, the product makes a double journey. According to research conducted by Twenga, a shopping search engine, the value of returns made globally in 2020 is a staggering 490 billion euros.
Let us not forget either old polluting means of transport, especially four-wheeled ones, which will inevitably have to make way for more ecological and green solutions, such as electric vehicles. Maritime transport is preferable to air transport because it has a lower impact, but it requires longer waiting times.
In this regard, also the fast deliveries result in higher greenhouse gas emissions. Take Amazon Prime, for example, which allows you to have a product delivered directly to your home within one day of purchase. According to research by Sendcloud, an e-commerce shipping platform, Italian consumers are increasingly conscious of the environmental impact of their actions, and 80% would be willing to wait a few extra days to make a sustainable choice.
How to improve the environmental impact of ecommerce?
E-commerce and sustainability can go hand in hand, but a change in mindset and some precautions are necessary, on everyone's part.
On the one hand, Online stores should empower customers and promote green and eco-friendly practices. For example, using recyclable packaging and providing the customer with all the information for sorting the materials, or making the customer aware of the impact that returns have on the environment, and so on.
On the other hand, All of us consumers have a great responsibility and a great power at the same time. Before purchasing an item, let's ask ourselves: can I wait a few more days for delivery or is it really that urgent? Can I find the same product in the store around the corner and walk there? Can I buy multiple products by placing a single order instead of making many just days apart?
Let's keep informing ourselves and raising awareness among those close to us; with our small choices, we can do a lot!
* CO2e is carbon dioxide equivalent: a unit of measurement used to calculate the impact of greenhouse gases on global warming, regardless of the type of gas.

Client Director for Flowerista. I come from the world of Digital Marketing, the kind that is gentle, delicate, and open to the constructive exchange of opinions. A compulsive reader, an animal and nature lover, I never tire of learning and challenging myself.